Questions to ask a lawyer about a settlement offer

Published by Book a Lawyer · Updated 20 September 2026

General information prepared with AI assistance and linked public sources. No independent legal review is claimed.

Coverage: Australian appointment preparation only. The legal effect of an offer, response, costs provision or settlement document requires advice on the particular matter.

General information only — not legal advice.

A settlement proposal is more than its headline amount. Take the complete offer and related documents to an adviser and ask what accepting, rejecting or responding could mean. Identify any stated response date promptly; this guide cannot assess whether an offer is suitable.

About 4 minutes · Includes a checklist and worked example

Bring the complete proposal

Keep the offer, covering email, attachments and any draft deed together. Note how and when the material was received and whether there are earlier versions. Tell the lawyer about any response already sent, including an informal reply, instead of assuming only a signed document matters.

An adviser needs to know the stage of the dispute and the current engagement arrangements. Ask whether reviewing the proposal and advising on a response are included in the existing scope or require a separate instruction.

Separate the amount from the obligations

Ask the lawyer to identify what each party would have to do. In addition to money, a proposal may discuss timing, documents, confidentiality, statements about the dispute or the end of particular claims. Do not infer the scope from a short email summary.

Request a plain-language explanation of any release or continuing obligation you do not understand. Ask what remains outside the proposed arrangement. The goal is a clear explanation from your adviser, not an attempt to interpret technical clauses through a checklist alone.

Discuss costs and practical performance

Ask which legal costs and outside expenses are included, excluded or still unresolved. A gross figure and the amount you would actually retain are not necessarily the same. Where appropriate, ask what other professional advice, such as tax advice, is needed before deciding.

Clarify proposed payment dates, instalments and required steps. Ask the lawyer what happens if performance is delayed or incomplete and whether the drafting addresses the issue. Record assumptions behind any illustrative calculation.

Clarify the response process

Show the adviser every stated response date and ask about any procedural or costs consequences that need prompt attention. Do not assume a request for clarification extends a deadline. Agree who will communicate the response and what authority they have.

If the proposal changes, ask whether the advice needs to be updated. Keep the final version distinguishable from drafts and confirm the steps needed after a decision. Avoid acting on a remembered verbal summary of terms you have not reviewed.

Read the proposal as a set of questions

A comparison note should expose the parts of the offer that still need professional explanation. It must not replace an assessment of the full terms.

Practical comparison framework
Part of proposal	Ask the adviser	Keep track of
Payment	What is included and what would remain payable?	Assumptions behind any calculation
Release or obligation	What does this cover and exclude?	Exact document version
Response	What timing or process matters?	Responsible person and known dates

How to use the comparison

A quick answer to the headline amount may leave important obligations unexplained. Tell the adviser about urgency while asking for the complete proposal to be assessed.

Your decision note should identify the advice received and unresolved questions, not just the amount offered.

Original editorial comparison framework. Examples are hypothetical and do not assess your circumstances.

Build your first-enquiry script →

Your practical checklist

Keep the full offer and attachments.
Identify versions and any response already sent.
Flag the stated response date immediately.
Ask about all obligations and the scope of release.
Clarify costs, payment and necessary specialist advice.
Agree who will communicate the response.

Open the appointment worksheets for notes you can keep privately.

Frequently asked questions

Can this guide tell me whether to accept?

No. That requires advice about your circumstances, the proposal and relevant law. The guide helps organise the questions for that advice.

Does asking for more time automatically extend the response date?

Do not assume it does. Ask the adviser to clarify the position and any timing consequences promptly.

Sources and further reading

Source references checked 20 September 2026. Follow the official source for current information and its jurisdictional limits. Our comparison prompts and hypothetical examples are editorial guidance, not statements of law.